The season felt slow, and almost all of us heard the same explanation: the sargassum. There it is, blocking the photo, stinking on the shore and scaring off reservations. Nobody's going to deny it. But when you sit down and look at the numbers calmly, the story turns out bigger than "the seaweed came and took the summer."
And the drop was sizable.
What the numbers show
From January to May, the Riviera's airports lost 645,210 passengers compared to last year. To put it in scale: that figure is 61% of everything Mexican beach destinations lost in the period. It's not that the whole country did badly across the board. The drop concentrated here.
Here's the first fact that doesn't fit the easy explanation. The sargassum isn't ours, it belongs to the whole Caribbean. The same Atlantic belt that reaches us washes our neighbors' coasts, and several of the destinations that grew the most this year sit under as much sargassum as we do, or more. Punta Cana, which competes room for room with Cancún, took 10.6% more arrivals from January to May while we lost ground. If the seaweed were enough to explain the drop, the drop would be everyone's. It isn't.
And it's not just Punta Cana. In the same period, Curaçao rose 9.0%, the Dominican Republic 10.0% and Aruba 10.4%, while Cancún fell 3.4%. What's interesting is where that growth came from. In none of them did it come from the U.S. market: the American visitor grew less than the total in each country. They grew by bringing people from elsewhere. Aruba is the clearest case: of its new arrivals, 58.7% of the growth were Argentines.
Two more figures are worth putting on the table, because they speak to our structure, not the weather.
The first: of every hundred foreigners who fly into Cancún, 76 come from just two countries, the United States and Canada. It's a solid base when those markets are strong. It's also a single bet when one of the two cools off.
The second has to do with what we charge and what we let in. A cruise passenger leaves, on average, 87 dollars in the country; a tourist who arrives by plane leaves 1,192, almost fourteen times more. They're two different businesses with the same sea in front of them, and it's worth knowing which one we're betting our infrastructure on.
One more, looking inward. The Riviera's formal wage is at its highest in about 30 years. It sounds like good news, and in part it is. But three of every four formal workers in the state earn between one and two minimum wages. The floor went up, not the ladder. It's a figure anyone who hires locally already feels in turnover and in the cost of keeping someone good.
None of this says what to do. It says where to look.
What's within our control?
Part of what happened isn't in our hands. The sargassum is regional. The weather, the cycles of the U.S. economy, the exchange rate, the perception of safety that gets cooked up far from here. Spending energy arguing about the seaweed as if it were the whole villain is comfortable, because it leaves us all as victims of something nobody chose.
But another part is decided locally, business by business, and that's the part worth putting on the table. Not as someone else's diagnosis, but as questions each of us answers for our own business.
How many markets does your clientele depend on, and what happens the day one cools off?
How easy or hard does your visitor have it before reaching your door, and once they're here?
And the most uncomfortable one: are we charging first-world prices and delivering an experience with third-world friction?
Those questions aren't answered by the weather. We answer them, or nobody does.
How other destinations overcame drops in demand
We aren't the first destination to watch its demand fall and have to decide what to do. Two examples, not as a recipe, but as proof that the conversation among private players works.
In Puerto Rico, after years of contraction, the private tourism sector pushed for a body now called Discover Puerto Rico, a destination marketing organization created by law in 2017, with its own budget and shielded from changes of government. The underlying idea: promoting the destination is too serious to leave at the mercy of the political calendar.
In Benidorm, a mature destination that has survived several crises, the hoteliers have shared and compared their occupancy data since 1985 through a common body. Each one still competes, but they all read the same numbers. Knowing, before your neighbor does, that a week is coming in slow is what lets you react instead of finding out late.
Neither of them solved anything with an article. They solved it by sitting down.
The conversation that comes next
An article can put the numbers on the table. It can't decide what the Riviera does with them. And that decision doesn't come from an analysis, it comes from sitting down, among those with a business at stake here, to look at the same data and think out loud about what's in our hands.
At Kiin Hub we believe that conversation is worth having, and we're thinking about how to do it right. No date yet, no commitment, no panel or endless open mic. A table of owners and directors who operate here.
If you'd like to be part of it when it takes shape, message us on WhatsApp at 990 403 6041. There's nothing to sign yet. Just stay tuned, this is only getting started.
Data: Riviera Maya Economic Pulse.
Share this article